Searching for Samuel (Book 2)

When Samuel doesn’t come home from work, his three little daughters wait by the window while their pregnant mother fears the worst. In Sugarcreek’s close-knit Amish community, a devoted father like Samuel would never abandon his family—but he’s vanished without a trace.

Amy never expected to find herself in the middle of a mystery when Lucas’s sister arrives at her farm in tears, begging for help. As Amy and Lucas join forces to search for the missing man, following Samuel’s bicycle route and questioning neighbors, their investigation reveals that even in peaceful Amish country, people sometimes harbor surprising secrets.

The deeper Amy and Lucas dig into Samuel’s disappearance, the more they realize how much they’ve come to depend on each other. Their partnership in solving this puzzle draws them closer than ever before, even as the differences between their worlds seem impossible to bridge.

As time runs out and the family’s worry grows, Amy discovers that sometimes the greatest mysteries aren’t just about finding the missing—they’re about finding the courage to trust your heart. In Sugarcreek, love and faith can overcome any obstacle, but first they must bring Samuel safely home to the little girls who need their daddy.

Back Cover Blurb:

When New York ghostwriter Amy Stanton inherits a farm in Amish country, she never expects to find herself in the middle of a mystery—or falling for the one man she can’t have.

Amy’s quiet new life in Sugarcreek, Ohio, takes a dramatic turn when her Amish farm manager’s brother-in-law vanishes without a trace. As she helps search for the missing man, Amy uncovers shocking family secrets—including the identity of her biological father and the truth about her glamorous mother’s hidden past.
Caught between two worlds, Amy’s growing feelings for stoic, honorable Lucas Hershberger force her to question everything she thought she knew.
Sometimes the family you find matters more than the one you’re born into.